What Should I Look For In A Good Mechanic?

June 23, 2023

Proud Mommy

When people have car troubles and they go online searching for a new mechanic they ask themselves, “What should I look for in a good mechanic?”. And in our opinion that should be a shop with a history of recurring customers and transparency . Many new shops have it tough as they haven’t built a history with a loyal client base. But any good shop will try their best to go above and beyond to earn the trust of their customers to get them to want to write reviews for them and come back to the shop as the experience was pleasant. Transparency, is when the mechanic shop staff takes the time to explain the problem and the repairs to you.

Fake Reviews and Other Tricks

When many people research a new local mechanic they quickly check to see what kind of reviews the shop gets. Unfortunately, there are many services that offer fake reviews. When looking at the reviews it is important to check the dates and make sure that all the positive reviews aren’t clustered on specific dates and months. If most of the shop’s reviews were posted within a few days of each other then you can guess that the reviews are not legitimate. Also look at the content of the reviews. When customers are very happy with the service they received they will usually write the reason why they really enjoyed the service the shop provided. Fake reviewers will post a one sentence ambiguous comment saying something like, “service was good.”.

A good shop will also be clean. The same way the cleanliness of the bathroom at a restaurant can give you an idea of how clean the kitchen is so can the cleanliness of a mechanic shop. Auto repair is dirty work and if the shop is not cared for it will quickly reflect that. That lack of care for the work environment can also reflect the level of care the staff has for their work they do and the business. The lack of cleanliness will affect the quality of the work the shop performs.

Explaining and Showing Their Work

A good mechanic shop, will have no problem taking the time to explain and show their work to you. Most people don’t know all the different components and parts that make a car work, but everybody can understand when they see something leaking, broken, rusty, or damaged. Everybody carries a high definition camera in their smart phone with a fast internet connection. A good mechanic shop will take the time to show you the damaged, leaking, broken, or rusty part with pictures or even better yet video.

A transparent shop will demonstrate how the part is broken and show you that evidence. We have seen other shops send pictures and videos of the whole car to their customers while stating in the video a part is broken or needs replacement without actually demonstrating the how or where the part is broken. Be careful of shops and dealers that refuse to include pictures or send you video that show you nothing.

In the video above you can see how our reputable shop’s service advisor records a video to send to our customer showing them how the bushing has play on the rear control arm in their vehicle. We demonstrate how the bushing has excessive play when force is applied to it. These bushings are supposed to have very little movement and the visible rust shows that the parts are old and worn.

These are the two most important things we have noticed when customers have come to us from less reputable shops asking us about our repair process. If you are local to Long Island City or Astoria, New York then feel free to give us a visit!

By Proud Mommy February 20, 2025
The 4th-generation Honda CR-V, was produced from 2012 to 2016, and is a reliable compact SUV popular with many of our customers. It is powered by a 2.4-liter engine and equipped with either a 5-speed automatic (2012–2014) or a CVT (2015–2016), it’s a common sight at our auto repair shop. However, even this popular model […]
By Proud Mommy February 5, 2025
The F15 BMW X5, was produced from 2013 to 2018, and is the third generation of BMW’s flagship luxury SUV. These are pretty popular cars among our customer base. However, like any vehicle, it has its share of common problems that owners and prospective buyers should be aware of. In this blog post, we’ll explore […]
By Proud Mommy December 18, 2024
At Tolima’s Auto Center, a common question we receive is whether we recommend dash cams and if we install them. The answer is a resounding yes, and here’s why you should consider one, particularly in light of recent insurance fraud schemes in New York City. Why Install a Dash Cam? How Dash Cams Work in […]
A person is fixing a brake caliper on a truck.
By Proud Mommy November 14, 2024
Today, we will be answering the most common questions we get about the yearly NY State Inspection. Every year, New Yorkers have to get their vehicles ready for their New York State inspection. The cost of the yearly inspection at the time of this blog post, is $37 to pass or fail. If you fail […]
A volkswagen tiguan is parked on the side of the road
By Proud Mommy September 17, 2024
Many customers contact us for auto body and collision work estimates for their cars, and we always emphasize the auto body and collision estimates based on pictures are rough estimates because we can’t properly estimate the amount of labor and parts for the car to be 100% repaired. We recently had a perfect example of […]
A tool box with a bunch of tools in it
By Proud Mommy August 20, 2024
We had a 2017 BMW 330i customer come in with a coolant leak. The car was regularly losing coolant so it was brought to our shop for diagnosis. We had to figure out why it was consistently losing coolant. For this type of diagnostics, we like to use a coolant pressure testing kit. The tool […]
By Proud Mommy June 26, 2024
Many first time customers come to our shop because their cars were diagnosed and repaired at another shop, but the original problem with their vehicle remains! Due to our proximity to Manhattan in Long Island City, we also get a lot of European vehicles which require advanced diagnostic and auto repair. Which means the car […]
By Proud Mommy June 20, 2024
We have noticed that Tesla has become more and more popular brand of vehicles in NYC and have more customers coming in with Tesla Model 3 owners come to our shop for maintenance and repairs. So we have decided to make a list of the most common issues and repairs we have seen in the […]
By Proud Mommy May 22, 2024
We recently had a customer come in with a 2019 Mercedes Benz GLC 300 that was overheating. The customer told us that it was taken to a different shop where they diagnosed the Mercedes Benz GLC and concluded that the cooling fan was faulty. They proceeded to replace it but the car continued to overheat. […]
By Proud Mommy April 15, 2024
Many customers text, call, or ask us in person, “How often should I change my oil?”. Particularly customers with European cars ask us if the 10,000 mile or 12 month oil change is often enough. And the answer is, it depends! There are multiple variables that determine how often you should change your oil. 10,000 […]